This blog is a forum for the posting of insights on the daf yomi (daily daf). Postings will be brief and to the point. Comments are welcome.
Wednesday, October 17, 2007
Kesubos 47b - Mekach Taos in Kiddushin
Click here for an explanation of Tosafos d.h. shelo, and an explanation of how we allow mekach taos by kiddushin when a woman marries someone who is found to have a major problem.
gevaldig! just one point, why does rav moshe need proofs from rashi, from the gemara regarding סימפון its clear that the concept of מקח טעות us possible, no?
r' moshe needs to prove that even when the problem is with him and she would want out, it can be a mekach taos. simpon is the opposite, it is a problem with her so he want out and by him there is no sevara of tan du.
4 comments:
gevaldig!
just one point, why does rav moshe need proofs from rashi, from the gemara regarding סימפון its clear that the concept of מקח טעות us possible, no?
r' moshe needs to prove that even when the problem is with him and she would want out, it can be a mekach taos. simpon is the opposite, it is a problem with her so he want out and by him there is no sevara of tan du.
do you have an updated working link for this pdf?
sorry.
try this:
https://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&pid=explorer&chrome=true&srcid=0B3MmXog7Se4fYjY2MDdkNzUtYmMwMi00OWJjLWE5OTYtOWUzNzBiYmJkZjM5&hl=en_US&authkey=CIa17d0G
Post a Comment